You might have Smeagle save one ally’s life, while Gollum betrays another later on - but that’s the point.

That one scene did more to make me sympathize with Gollum than anything in Tolkien’s work, with its glimpse inside Gollum’s tortured mind and the sad remnants of who he used to be - and sometimes still wanted to be.

I convinced Gollum that the beetle was not, in fact, a spy, and was treated to a scene where Smeagle watches with an almost pathetic sense of childlike wonder as the insect flies around his head - before Ringwraith butts in and ruins the moment.Ĭhoices have impact even if Smeagle’s fate is sealed. You need to make a compelling argument against Smeagle or Gollum to get the desired outcome, which adds a surprising sense of weight to seemingly inconsequential decisions. In one early scene, for example, you have to decide whether Gollum will let a beetle live or crush it. Some decisions popped up at completely unexpected moments and had equally unexpected - sometimes even beautiful - outcomes. These choices let you piece together a portrait of his fragile personality and get a better understanding of the struggles he faces, explaining why Smeagle eventually gives in to Gollum. Gollum’s story is a known entity, so instead of trying to do something new and daring with it, Daedalic takes the introspective route. The clever thing about Gollum’s choices, however, is that they don’t have to matter. I only had time for one playthrough, and you get just one save file. It’s tough to say what effect, if any, these have on the broader narrative. Gollum finds himself at a crossroad during some key moments, where he can either cave into his own horrible demands or let Smeagle’s better nature shine through.

The lord of the rings cartoon gollum